Jaguar vs. Mercedes: Reliability

Jaguar vs. Mercedes: Reliability

Jaguar and Mercedes are some of the best European luxury car brands. Both of these brands boast superior engineering, comfort, and lovely designs. But how do they compare in terms of reliability? Benz takes the lead.

Mercedes-Benz beats Jaguar hands down in terms of reliability. Even though Jaguar has improved a lot in the past few years, Mercedes is still one of the most reliable luxury car brands on the market. Jaguar usually has a reliability score of about 86%, while Benz has around 93%.

The least reliable Jaguar according to consumer reports is the Jaguar XJ. This car experiences several problems that are connected to the battery, engine, infotainment system, interior trim, and suspension. Mercedes-Benz C-Class is the least reliable Mercedes model.

Which car is more reliable – Jaguar or Mercedes?

When picking a car, it’s important to consider other factors apart from its looks and reliability. Factors like performance, comfort, price, and safety are also vital. Here are some of the popular Jaguar and Mercedes-Benz models and how they compare to one another.

Jaguar XF or Mercedes-Benz E-Class

If you’re looking for a midsize luxury sedan, you may be undecided when selecting between the Jaguar XF and Mercedes-Benz E-Class. Both of these luxury cars come with fantastic features and high-end technology. That’s why buyers are normally confused when it comes to choosing between the two.

  Porsche vs. Range Rover: Reliability


Mercedes E-Class is more reliable than the Jaguar XF. Thanks to the fewer reported failure problems than the Jaguar XF. What’s more, the Mercedes E-Class lasts longer than the Jaguar XF. Therefore, it’s also a good investment for people who want a car that lasts long.


First and foremost, Jaguar XF and Mercedes E-Class both come with classic and elegant exterior designs. But when you look closely, Jaguar XF has a better design and appeal than the E-Class. So, in terms of looks, the XF has an edge over the E-Class.


Both of these luxury sedans perform well. However, the Jaguar XF performs somewhat better than the Mercedes E-Class. They feature a 2.0-liter inter-cooled turbo premium unleaded I-4 engine. The XF has an RWD system, while the E-Class has an AWD system.


Luxury car brands produce some of the safest vehicles on the market. So, whether you pick Jaguar XF or Mercedes-Benz E-Class, you’re guaranteed to drive a safe car. However, Mercedes-Benz E-Class comes with more sophisticated safety features than Jaguar.


As expected, the Mercedes-Benz E-Class is slightly more expensive than the Jaguar XF. The Jaguar XF has a starting price of around $44,000, while the Mercedes E-Class has a starting price of about $57,800. Nevertheless, both cars are worth their price, as the Mercedes E-Class comes with more advanced features than the Jaguar XF.

Jaguar XE or Mercedes-Benz C-Class


Despite the C-Class being the least reliable Mercedes model, this car still ranks higher than the Jaguar XE in terms of reliability. Nonetheless, both of these cars will cost you a lot to maintain in the long term. On the same note, the Jaguar XE ($42,950) has a higher starting price than the Mercedes C-Class ($42,650).

  Porsche vs. Ferrari Reliability - Which is better?


If you want a small luxury sedan, the Jaguar XE and Mercedes C-Class are the best options. Even though Jaguar is known for its beautiful exterior looks, the C-Class gives the XE a run for its money, as it’s also well-built. Both of their interiors look pristine and lavish but they are slightly cramped.


Performance-wise, the Jaguar XE performs somewhat better than the Mercedes-Benz C-Class. But if you pick the C-Class AMG line, then the XE lags. The C-Class is fitted with a rear-wheel-drive system, while the XE comes with an all-wheel-drive system, which is perfect for all terrains.


Both of these small luxury sedans are safe as they are fitted with some of the best safety technology on the market. The Jaguar XE boasts features such as electronic stability control, lane keep assist, and departure warning. Mercedes C-Class has blind spot assist, electronic stability control, and Mercedes Me connect. 


Which luxury car is the most reliable – Audi, BMW, Mercedes or Jaguar?

Among these four exceptional brands, Mercedes is the most reliable car, followed by BMW. Jaguar is the least reliable car and in the third place is the Audi. What makes Audi fall behind its close competitors is the expensive repairs that owners have to endure as it ages.

Why do Jaguars have a reputation of being unreliable?

Jaguars are normally considered unreliable because of the poor quality of cars that they manufactured in the 1950s and 1960s. At this time, they were owned by the British Leyland, which never emphasized the quality of the cars that they made.

What’s more, Jaguars made before the 1970s were quite costly compared to many other cars, but very unreliable. As a result, their reputation was tarnished. But when Ford took over the company, things changed and they started producing some of the best-designed and reliable cars on the market.

  Are Mercedes cars reliable after 100k miles?

Which car should I buy – Jaguar or Mercedes?

It depends on your budget and needs. If you want a unique and beautifully designed luxury car, Jaguar is the best choice. But if you want class, luxury, and comfort, then Mercedes is the better option. Nevertheless, both of these cars are outstanding and in a class of their own.

Which car is more prestigious – Mercedes or Jaguar?

Mercedes is the more prestigious brand. This is because it has maintained the high standards over the years, while Jaguar’s reputation has been up and down. Besides, Mercedes has an exceptional collection of cars that put it above Jaguar, which offers limited models.

Which luxury car offers a better driving experience – BMW, Audi, Jaguar, or Mercedes?

If you want to enjoy your ride, BMW is the best car to choose. Thanks to its outstanding performance and handling. On top of that, it’s driver-focused, meaning you will have ample time driving the car. Next in line is the Audi, Jaguar, and finally, Mercedes-Benz.

For luxurious reliability: Go with Mercedes

If you want a reliable luxury car, Mercedes is the better car. As both of these cars age, Jaguar will command more repairs, which are also costlier than Mercedes. Furthermore, Jaguar ages faster than Mercedes, which is not a good thing.

All-in-all, both of these cars are exceptional in performance and very comfortable. If you desire style and uniqueness, Jaguar is a fantastic choice. Additionally, Jaguar is slightly cheaper than Mercedes-Benz, but with high-tech features.

Edwin Odipo

Why do you love writing about cars? Cars make our lives easy. You can visit your distant friend, relative or even rush to the grocery store a few miles from your home with a lot of ease. Imagine how life was before the invention of cars?? To me, cars are a blessing that made life more convenient.

Recent Posts