What are the best used cars for safety and reliability?

If you’re in the market for the best-used cars for safety and reliability, there are lots of options to select from. Simply select the right second-hand car for your budget and needs.

The best-used cars for safety and reliability include Toyota Yaris, Honda Fit, Honda Accord, Volkswagen Jetta, Toyota Prius, and Subaru Impreza. These cars have an excellent track record for both safety and reliability. Most of them are ranked highly on Consumer Reports and other reliability rating agencies.

Below is a list of the top used cars for safety and reliability:

Toyota Yaris (2011 – present)

On top of our list is the Toyota Yaris from model 2011 and beyond. This compact Japanese car is one of the best compact cars on the market. Not only is this lovely hatchback beautiful and fuel-efficient, but it also ranks highly in many safety and reliability ratings.

The Toyota Yaris also comes with a front-wheel-drive system. The car is easy and fun to handle and drive with its outstanding driving dynamics. With a seating capacity of five, this is a perfect car for new drivers and families. Besides, a used Toyota Yaris is cheap as it costs around $14,000.

2012 Honda Fit

If you’re looking for a reliable subcompact car, then Honda Fit should be on top of your list. Apart from being safe and reliable, Honda Fit is simple to maintain and with great gas mileage. The only issue with this car is the Sat-nav. A used Honda Fit goes for around $13,000.

  Are Volvo reliable used cars?

Like the Toyota Yaris, Honda Fit comes with a front-wheel-drive system and a 5-passenger capacity. But unlike most subcompact cars, Honda Fit is quite spacious with a larger cargo area. It’s the best-used car on this list for people looking for quality and value.

Toyota Prius Prime (2017 or newer)

Overall, Toyota makes some of the most reliable cars on the market. So, it’s not a surprise that three of the best-used cars for safety and reliability on our list are from Toyota. The Toyota Prius Prime is another reliable and safe car for first-time drivers. A used Toyota Prius Prime goes for about $20,000.
The Toyota Prius Prime is the best-used hybrid car for safety and reliability. So, if you’re looking to go green but don’t have the money to spend on a new car, this is the best choice. Not only does it boasts exceptional safety features, but it also delivers class-leading mileage of 133 MPGe.

Volkswagen Jetta (2016 – 2018)

Volkswagen Jetta is the most popular Volkswagen model of the last decade. On top of that, it’s one of the safest and most reliable Volkswagen models along with the Volkswagen Passat. What’s more, this model retails at an excellent price in the used car market at around $21,000.

What makes the Volkswagen Jetta stand out from cars in its class is its lovely and elegant design. Additionally, the car is spacious with a lot of room for 5 passengers. Another exceptional feature of the Jetta is the intuitive infotainment features. Unlike most cars in its class, this model is very fuel-efficient.

Mazda 3

If you want the best car for an inexperienced driver, the Mazda 3 hatchback or sedan is the best choice. This small car ranks highly in terms of safety, reliability, and fuel efficiency. Moreover, it has fantastic handling, excellent power, and it’s fun to drive. A used Mazda 3 goes for around $19,500.

  What is the cheapest electric car?

Honda Accord Sedan (2013 or newer)

A quality used Honda Accord goes for around $25,000. Even though this price is slightly higher compared to the used cars on this list, you get what you pay for. The Honda Accord is more luxurious, spacious, and performs better than most vehicles. In addition, it’s safe, reliable, and efficient.

Subaru Impreza (2014 or newer)

The Subaru Impreza is another quality used car for safety and reliability. Fitted with an all-wheel-drive powertrain, this car can easily cruise on different terrains, making it the best all-weather used car on this list. A used Subaru Impreza may cost around $20,500.

Toyota Avalon

For the lovers of large sedans, the Toyota Avalon is the best used large sedan for safety and reliability. It’s also the largest sedan on this list and boasts of a variety of safety features. Besides, it’s spacious, luxurious, and reliable. Thanks to its lower maintenance cost. A used Toyota Avalon will cost around $19,000.

Buick LaCrose

Last but not least, the Buick LaCrose is another excellent used car with good safety and reliability ratings. Apart from that, it also comes with a luxurious interior that rivals luxury sedans. Despite featuring several fantastic features, a used Buick LaCrose is affordable and goes for about $21,000.


What used cars are unreliable?

If you’re in the market for a used car, there are some cars that you should avoid at all costs. These cars are very unreliable and will cost you even more in the long run. They include the 2008 Dodge Avenger, Audi A6, Mitsubishi Mirage, Jaguar XJ, Mercedes-Benz C-Class, Peugeot 308, and KIA Picanto.

  What Is The Worst Audi To Buy Used?

What are the best-used cars for teens?

When parents buy a car for their teens, they always look for a safe, reliable, and affordable car. Since teens are inexperienced and may be tempted to drive fast, buying them a faster car is not recommended at all.

So, if you want to keep your teenagers safe and secure as they learn how to drive, buy them a very reliable and safe car. The best cars for teens include 2011 or newer Mazda 3, 2012 or newer Honda Accord, 2011 to 2015 Ford Taurus,

What to avoid before buying a used car?

Many used car buyers make some mistakes that end up costing them in the long term. When you’re buying a used car, avoid the seller rushing you into buying the car. Take your time to inspect and test the car. Also, always check the VIN and vehicle history before paying off.


Now that you know the best-used cars for safety and reliability, picking the best car for your needs and budget shouldn’t be an issue. All of the cars that we’ve listed are affordable and very reliable. Just ensure to pick a car that appeals to your taste and personality.

Marko Mikulic

Why do you love writing about cars? I love writing about cars as cars are a huge personal interest of mine. I was raised in a car enthusiast community and ever since I was young, I always wanted to do car-related work.

Recent Posts