Audi and Toyota are both in the business of making cars for a long time which means that they know a thing or two about making great cars. However, they do so very differently as Toyota prioritizes affordability, reliability, and efficiency while Audi prioritizes luxury, innovation, and desirability.
These two different approaches mean that Toyota inherently makes better cars that are likely to last longer. This does not mean that Audi makes cars that are of lesser quality, but rather that most Audi’s are a lot more complex and thus are more likely to experience issues.
According to most reliability charts, Toyota is at the very top of the list with the likes of Honda and Lexus while Audi is mediocre. Older Audi models are indeed a bit more difficult to keep running when compared to older Toyota models.
However, how reliable your car is going to be is dependent on many different factors such as maintenance, mileage, the overall condition, and your driving habits.
Audi reliability – Mediocre as a whole and highly dependent on proper maintenance
Audi approaches making cars with a clear emphasis on luxury, technology, and innovation. This makes all modern Audi’s filled with all sorts of technology features and gadgets which tends to separate Audi models from brands like Toyota because they are not nearly as luxurious.
Secondly, Audi customers are not all that worried about lackluster Audi reliability because people who buy Audi’s from new usually keep them until the warranty inevitably runs out. All of this indicates that Audi’s does not need to be incredibly reliable in order to sell well which is not the case with a Toyota.
Many world’s most prominent reliability surveys and charts ran by organizations and outlets such as Consumer Reports, WhatCar, and J.D. Power deem Audi to be mediocre. Currently, the most reliable Audi is the A4 as the platform on which it is built is a few years old thus is refined as much as possible.
The least reliable Audi cars are now one or two decades old and you should not be surprised if you encounter issues with a 20-year-old German luxury car.
Toyota reliability – Industry-leading
No other car brand out there is able to consistently dominate many car reliability charts and surveys in the same way as Toyota. Almost all leading reliability charts list at least a few Toyota models as class-leading in their respective segments.
This is the reason why many people are willing to buy a Toyota because Toyota aims for superior reliability as reliability is one of the main reasons why one even wants to buy a Toyota. As such, Toyota as a whole is a lot more reliable than Audi, but there are a few distinct reasons why.
The first was is down to market placement as Toyota is aimed at people who are not all that enthusiastic about luxury or performance. People are willing to sacrifice reliability and affordability when it comes to luxury cars as luxury cars are status symbols and they are better from many other perspectives.
Secondly, Toyota makes simpler cars that tend to use older technologies that are known to last a long time. Toyota is more willing to adapt and evolutionize when it comes to changing certain crucial elements while Audi is willing to revolutionize in order to maintain a luxury brand name.
Conclusion – Toyota is the clear winner
Toyota takes the cake as the more reliable car brand of the two, and the differences between them are vast. Audi models need frequent and thorough maintenance if you want to enjoy them for the longest because they are more complex, more technologically driven, and more fragile.
Toyota models often use less sophisticated construction methods which are known to be of lesser quality but are able to last longer. This does not mean that they don’t need maintenance, the only difference is how frequent and how extensive the maintenance is.
That is also why Audi’s tend to cost a lot more to run, especially in the case of some higher-end models. Audi still uses V10s, a W12 engine, and a fair bit of V8s while Toyota is primarily relying on the good old trusty 2.0L 4-cylinder.
Finally, Audi customers are willing to sacrifice reliability because they want premium products and because reliability is not really a strong selling point for an Audi. On the other hand, Toyota bases its market appeal on reliability a lot more.
Video: Audi Q7 VS Toyota Land Cruiser tug of war
Which is better Audi or Toyota in a tug of war?
What is the most reliable Audi model?
Currently, the most reliable Audi model is the Audi A4 because it is based on a relatively old platform that has been progressively upgraded throughout all the preceding model years of the current generation A4. This means that Audi uses the same platform from 2015, and with each subsequent year, they are able to iron out some of the imperfections.
The 1.8L and the 2.0L 4-cylinder gas-powered engines are currently the most reliable Audi engines because they are being shared with many VAG products.
What is the most reliable Toyota model?
The Toyota Prius and the Toyota 4Runner are the two most reliable Toyota models because they are built on a dependable and long-lasting chassis. The Prius is partially so successful because it is so reliable as many people interested in the Prius are not interested in anything else besides a long-lasting A to B automobile.
The 4Runner is based on an old school off-roader platform which means that it is built tough and is able to last a long time because of that.
Why is Lexus more reliable than Audi?
Lexus consistently makes more reliable cars than Audi even though Lexus is also a luxury brand. That’s why many people wonder why Audi does not make equally reliable cars. The truth of the matter is that they don’t need to make superiorly reliable cars in order for them to succeed.
Audi shifts many models each year and hardly anyone who buys them is focused on buying the most reliable car on the planet. There are different types of priorities and not everyone is so focused on buying the toughest products out there.