Porsche and Range Rover are leagues apart when it comes to reliability. And the reason why is that Porsche tries as much as possible to offer a reliable car. The average Porsche customer is somewhat of an enthusiast who takes excellent care of their cars.
On the other hand, Land Rover wants uniqueness, specialness, and exclusivity. As such, Land Rover doesn’t want to share parts with anyone, and that’s one of the reasons why a Range Rover is so unreliable. In addition, people who buy Range Rovers don’t care as much about reliability.
According to a 2020 most reliable brand study by J.D. Power, Porsche placed 4th with 104 problems reported per 100 cars. On the other hand, Land Rover finished last with 220 problems per 100 cars. The level of reliability disparity between these two brands is huge.
But such surveys don’t always tell the whole story, as it is much more important to know how a specific owner treats his or her car. Porsche owners are usually way more enthusiastic about cars, which means that they do take better care of their cars.
Porsche reliability
A few decades ago, Porsches were not all that reliable. But thanks to increased levels of attention to detail, sophisticated R&D, and greatly improved manufacturing methods, Porsche vehicles have become some of the most reliable models on the market.
According to a couple of Porsche insiders, the main reason why Porsches are so reliable is that Porsche staff tries incredibly hard to increase the levels of sophistication of each and every part, as often as humanly possible.
This means that Porsche takes pride in knowing that people truly do love Porsches. Hardly any other brand out there has such a cult following and such a loyal customer base as Porsche has. That being said, an average Porsche owner takes better care of their cars, especially when compared to a Range Rover owner.
The most reliable Porsche model is the 911. The reason why is that 911 has constantly been improved throughout the last couple of decades. The 911 platform is as good as it can be, and even after such a long time in continuous production, Porsche still manages to find new ways of improving it.
Range Rover reliability
The fact of the matter is that Range Rovers are probably not as unreliable as everyone thinks they are, because it truly does seem like Range Rovers are utter trash when it comes to reliability. But people still buy them, and people still enjoy them with every newer generation.
It’s weird that a company with such a low level of reliability is still considered as a staple of British luxury. But that’s because Land Rover took a different approach through marketing and clever product placement and celebrity endorsements.
Range Rovers are incredibly complex, so much so that it really is no surprise that they are unreliable as a result. A modern-day Range Rover is an amazing luxury SUV with loads of space, technology, and luxury. But at the same time, it also offers class-leading off-roading capabilities which is rarely the case with true luxury SUVs.
And if you pair that with iconic design, celebrity endorsements, and the general craze over SUVs, Range Rovers are still being sold left and right. But, after a couple of years, people tend to sell their luxury SUVs after all the warranties expire, and that’s when true hell breaks loose.
What does luxury truly mean and why do people buy Range Rovers?
There is a common misconception out there that luxury corresponds to quality. Luxury does not necessarily mean quality; luxury is more about exclusivity. After all, if we all drove Range Rovers, no one would be special, which is one reason why Range Rovers are so popular.
Range Rovers offer amazing luxury, comfort, practicality, off-roading capabilities, and so on. True engineering strives to incorporate the simplest solutions to problems, and those solutions are usually pretty reliable. However, Range Rover seems to be the complete opposite.
It surely isn’t a surprise that Range Rovers are unreliable, since they’ve had that reputation for a long time. Yet they are exclusive status symbols, and people want other people to know that they have the money to afford such an SUV, even if it costs more.
Porsches are kind of similar if you consider the Cayenne and the Panamera, but these two are way more reliable. On the other hand, 911s are bought by sports car lovers, and an average 911 owner is most likely a car enthusiast in some form or fashion.
Video: BMW X5 vs Range Rover Sport vs Porsche Cayenne S Coupe | SUV Showcase
FAQ
Is Land Rover trying to make more reliable cars?
Of course they are, everyone tries to make reliable products. But the difference here is that Land Rover does not prioritize reliability, as reliability is not prioritized by the typical Land Rover customer.
In the same way Toyota prioritizes reliability because Toyota customers prioritize reliability, Land Rover prioritizes style, luxury, and status because a Range Rover customer prioritizes style, luxury, and fashion.
Does Land Rover make more luxurious cars than Porsche?
Between the two brands, Porsche is the more luxurious one as the levels of sophistication and technology are superior in most Porsche models. Even though a Range Rover is luxurious and exclusive, Porsche makes hypercars, so there is really no comparison.
If luxury is exclusivity (and it is), a Porsche 918 Spyder is unmatched when it comes to luxury. The exclusivity factor is further reiterated by a million-dollar price tag.
Does Porsche make better SUVs compared to Land Rover?
It depends on what you are after. If you want a sporty SUV with superior reliability and technology, go for the Porsche Cayenne. If you value style, status, comfort and off-roading, go for the Range Rover. And the same story goes throughout the entire SUV ranges of both manufacturers.
Between the two, it’s hard to argue with the iconic status a Range Rover possesses, even though the reliability is nowhere close to backing that up. On the other hand, the Porsche 911 is also an undisputed icon, but with stout reliability to back it up.