BMW and Tesla are some of the best car manufacturers in the world today. However, while BMW excels at making some of the best gasoline-powered cars, Tesla is the best electric car manufacturer in the world. But which car is better between the 2022 BMW X5 and Tesla Model Y?
Tesla Model Y is suitable for individuals who desire high-performance, highly advanced, and spacious mid-size SUVs. While BMW X5 is best for people who prefer a traditional SUV design with a luxurious interior, and stylish exterior. Nonetheless, both cars perform exceptionally well and are advanced.
Which mid-size luxury SUV is better – BMW X5 or Tesla Model Y?
Appearance
Tesla may be the car for the future, but its design is not very appealing compared to the BMW X5. This is because BMW X5 comes with stunning features that will leave onlookers perplexed. On the contrary, Tesla Model Y’s exterior design is simple, making it less attractive than the BMW X5.
Additionally, BMW X5’s interior also looks more upscale than Tesla Model Y’s interior. This is because Tesla uses simple materials, while BMW X5 materials are more luxurious. Besides, Tesla Model Y seats are not as cozy as BMW X5’s seats.
However, Tesla Model Y has one of the best infotainment systems in its class. It comes with an infotainment display centered on a simple dashboard. And with the large panoramic sunroof that covers most parts of the roof, the ambiance in the car is otherworldly.
BMW X5 also has a nice infotainment system that is user-friendly. Aside from this, it comes with seats that are not only cozy but also made of Vernasca leather. It also has a leather dashboard and beautiful finishes that define class and elegance.
The BMW X5 is slightly bigger than the Tesla Model Y as it has a wheelbase of 117.1-inches, a length of 194.3-inches, a width of 78.9-inches, and a height of 63.7-inches. Tesla has a wheelbase of 113.8-inches, a length of 187-inches, a width of 75.6-inches, and a height of 63.9-inches.
Performance
BMW X5 and Tesla Model Y are some of the best-performing cars in their class, alongside the Porsche Cayenne. However, the Tesla Model Y performs slightly better than the BMW X5. While the BMW X5 M50i can accelerate from 0 to 60 in 3.8 seconds, the Tesla Model Y Performance variant only takes up to 3.6 seconds.
Tesla Model Y is equipped with a 75-kWh battery that also provides up to 326 miles for the Long-Range variant and 303 miles for the performance variant. While the BMW X5 has three engine options, which include the 3.0-liter turbo inline-6, 3.0-liter turbo inline-6 hybrid, and 4.4-liter twin-turbo V8 engines.
Comfort and Cargo space
Both cars come with a spacious interior and a large cargo area. The BMW X5 has a slightly large cargo area with a total of 72.3 cubic feet, while the Tesla Model Y has a total of 68 cubic feet. When it comes to cabin space, Tesla Model Y has more legroom, both in the front and rear than BMW X5.
Price
The Tesla Model Y is slightly cheaper than the BMW X5. This is quite surprising as these cars have near performance level and features. But since the BMW X5 is more luxurious with an upscale interior, it is worth the extra dollars.
Are you considering a Tesla? Tesla lease vs buy
The base Tesla Model Y Long Range variant goes for about $60,440, while the base BMW X5 sDrive40i goes for around $6,300. So, even though the difference is small, BMW X5 is slightly costlier.
FAQ
Which car is more reliable – BMW X5 or Tesla Model Y?
Tesla Model Y is more reliable than BMW X5. Even though Tesla has had build quality issues, their cars have always been reliable. So, if you want a car that won’t make you spend more time in the garage, the answer is the Tesla Model Y. the BMW X5 is one of the least reliable cars in the class.
Which car is faster – Tesla Model Y or BMW X5?
Tesla Model Y is the faster car. The Tesla Model Y Performance variant delivers a top speed of up to 155 mph. It can also accelerate from 0 to 60 in 3.6 seconds. This is better than the BMW X5 M50i trim with a top speed of 155 mph and acceleration of 3.8 seconds from 0 to 60.
Can Tesla Model Y accommodate up to seven passengers?
Just like the BMW X5, you can also get a Tesla Model Y with third-row seating. Nonetheless, the third-row for the Tesla Model Y is just as cramped as the third-row in BMW X5. So, it is better for kids than adults. But Unlike BMW X5’s third row, Tesla includes two cup holders for the occupants of these seats.
Does BMW have a fully electric SUV?
Yes, BMW has the BMW ix3 all-electric SUV. However, this electric SUV cannot compete with the Tesla Model Y as it lacks in many areas. For instance, the ix3 covers fewer miles and does not perform as well as the Tesla Model Y. So, BMW needs to make a lot of improvements if they are to compete with Tesla.
Which car will last longer – BMW X5 or Tesla Model Y?
Since Tesla is an electric car, expect it to have a longer lifespan than the BMW X5, which is powered by gasoline. If properly maintained, Tesla Model Y can last between 300,000 and 500,000 miles. Besides, Tesla is working on a battery that can last over 1,000,000 miles.
On the contrary, the BMW X5 is only good up to 150,000 miles, which is not good enough. But if properly maintained, the X5 can also clock over 200,000 miles. All in all, Tesla Model Y will last longer as the battery can be replaced when it wears out.
Conclusion
Even though these two cars vary in many ways, they are still both mid-size luxury SUVs. The BMW X5 is exceptional for individuals looking for a luxurious, comfortable, and stylish SUV. While the Tesla Model Y is perfect for people who desire a high-performance, spacious, and highly advanced SUV.
Despite these cars having similar features, the Tesla Model Y offers value for money as it’s cheaper, more economical, and performs better than the BMW X5.
