Although both have their own problems, Volvo ranks higher than Jaguar in terms of reliability.
Volvo was always a pretty reliable brand, but lately, it has regressed in terms of reliability. Both Volvo and Jaguar are not the ideal car companies in terms of reliability, but Volvo still outruns Jaguar its German rivals, due to its safety and luxury features.
Volvo vs Jaguar – which is better? Let’s have a look.
Jaguar’s questionable reliability
Jaguar has been one of the most unreliable car companies for decades. In the past, they even brought British manufacturers’ ranking down overall because of their unreliability. In 2014, Warranty Direct put the UK in last place, which was partially due to the unreliability and problems found in Jaguar.
Jaguar, with Land Rover, was the reason why UK cars were termed as the worst in reliability. Land Rover also plays a big part in Jaguar’s unreliability, and they have a high annual average repair cost of $1,123. However, they have improved their rankings a bit recently.
Jaguar scored 171 in ReliabilityIndex’s ratings, which is not the greatest score, but they have managed to outrun some of their British competitors like Bentley, which only scored 529. They have even reduced their problems per 100 cars to 186. Overall, they still rank as average in terms of reliability, but some of their cars score much better than other poor-scorers like the Jaguar XF. They still cost more to repair, but they are improving.
Problems with Jaguar
With their high repair costs, having problems with your Jaguar can truly be a nightmare. Unfortunately, they do often come with some problems. After a little over 100,000 miles, the transmission system has been reported to experience some failures. Transmission repairs are usually very expensive.
Some customers have reported some water leakage issues with their Jaguars. Luckily, this is probably just due to outer door seals, which can be fixed cheaply. The coolant tank has also been reported to experience some leakages, resulting in the engine overheating. The braking systems are also prone to having issues as well.
Some customers have also reported problems with the suspension system, which experiences some wear and tear after a while. At the same time, some older models have faced issues with the ignition coil. These issues are very expensive to repair, at an average of around $800.
Volvo’s reliability has varied
Volvo used to have a reputation for extremely durable and reliable cars, but lately, they have faced some unreliability issues. This is partly due to the fact that Volvo has shifted its focus towards more complex cars with new technology that have experienced some faults.
Volvo doesn’t have the best reliability scores, but they still outrun German and British car manufacturers. ReliabilityIndex gives Volvo a score of 127, which is a pretty decent score in terms of reliability. They do have a high number of problems per 100 cars though, with a score of 185. They rank 23rd out of 30 car brands.
However, Volvo is still the best in terms of safety features and durability. They have made more safety features as standard than any other brand. They still outrun the big luxury brands like Audi or BMW. With the introduction of the XC40, their reliability has improved a bit recently.
Problems with Volvo
Volvo faces some problems and some of them are quite expensive to fix. The transmission system failure is the biggest reported problem in Volvos. Many of the new models have the transmission system from Aisin technology, which customers don’t seem to love. The transmission system also has a high repair cost of around $3,500.
Some other major and minor issues include a leakage problem with the power steering fluid. Some drivers have also experienced problems with the auto-braking system, while others have faced problems with engine overheating due to an engine cooling fan failure. The majority of these issues have been reported in the XC90, which has been termed as the most unreliable Volvo car.
Volvo vs. Jaguar
Both Volvo and Jaguar have faced some similar issues like transmission failures or engine overheating. However, Volvo still has the best safety features, making them pretty reliable. Neither brand is at the top of reliability rankings, but Volvos do have fewer problems per 100 cars and a better reliability score.
Jaguar also produces a sports car that has a 5.0 L supercharged engine. Volvo mainly focuses on luxury cars, so they don’t have any competitors with the F-Type. However, if we compare some similar cars like Volvo’s XC40 with Jaguar’s E-Pace, then Volvo clearly wins.
If you’re looking for a luxury car with maximum comfort and better driving experience, then Volvo is the answer. Volvo has a minimalistic style that many people like. They are not super fast, but they get things done with great consistency. However, if you want a sporty car, then Jaguar will have you covered.
Video: BMW X2 vs Volvo XC40 vs Jaguar E-Pace – which is the best small SUV? | Head-2-Head
FAQ
What is car reliability?
The reliability of a car means people trust the car due to its job with consistency, few repairs, and an overall good driving experience. Reliability depends on major factors like safety, repair bills, and fuel-efficiency. People want to buy a car that doesn’t break down every day and isn’t too expensive when it does.
One way to figure out if a car is reliable is to check out car surveys or car reviews, which will help decide what to buy.
Why does a car’s reliability matter?
The reliability of a car is very important if you want to buy a car that lasts a long time. People don’t want to face engine problems daily and that’s why they choose some of the more reliable brands like Toyota, Mazda, or Honda over other shiny brands. Choosing more reliable brands even helps you spend less on your car overall.
Does Jaguar have high resale value?
Jaguar is not known for holding their value. They surely make some fast and shiny cars, but longevity and reselling are not their strong suits. During the Covid-19 pandemic, they are reported to have depreciated even more than before. They had a depreciation of around 38.5% in 2019.
